Skip to main content
Back to songs

Jhoola · 1962

Ek Samay Par Do Barsaten

Hindi-film eligibility matched; song credits may still need checking

Singer: Manna Dey

Music: Salil Chowdhury

Recording: original

Metadata references

Release and credit references do not establish a raag or taal attribution.

Reported raag

Sur Malhar

Not yet reviewed by a musician

A named writer on music analysed the song in this raag as one of several raags in the song. This records what the source says; a musician has not checked the recording note by note. The source quotes पंकज राग, धुनों की यात्रा, पृ.471.

Evidence: Named musician's analysis · Amrita Dutta, doctoral thesis (University of Delhi, 2018), ch.2, printed p.103 (PDF p.56), composer discussion / prose example

Source wording: “‘झूला’ (1962) का गीत ‘एक समय पर दो बरसातें’ (मन्ना डे, सुर मल्हार+मेघ+मियाँ की मल्हार) के शास्त्रीय रंगों के साथ स्वरों का उतार-चढ़ाव भी बहुत ही प्रभावी असर पैदा करता है।” · Applies to: mixed

Need the attribution logic? Read how film-song raags are identified.

Reported raag

Megh

Not yet reviewed by a musician

A named writer on music analysed the song in this raag as one of several raags in the song. This records what the source says; a musician has not checked the recording note by note. The source quotes पंकज राग, धुनों की यात्रा, पृ.471.

Evidence: Named musician's analysis · Amrita Dutta, doctoral thesis (University of Delhi, 2018), ch.2, printed p.103 (PDF p.56), composer discussion / prose example

Source wording: “‘झूला’ (1962) का गीत ‘एक समय पर दो बरसातें’ (मन्ना डे, सुर मल्हार+मेघ+मियाँ की मल्हार) के शास्त्रीय रंगों के साथ स्वरों का उतार-चढ़ाव भी बहुत ही प्रभावी असर पैदा करता है।” · Applies to: mixed

Need the attribution logic? Read how film-song raags are identified.

Reported raag

Mian Ki Malhar

Not yet reviewed by a musician

A named writer on music analysed the song in this raag as one of several raags in the song. This records what the source says; a musician has not checked the recording note by note. The source quotes पंकज राग, धुनों की यात्रा, पृ.471.

Evidence: Named musician's analysis · Amrita Dutta, doctoral thesis (University of Delhi, 2018), ch.2, printed p.103 (PDF p.56), composer discussion / prose example

Source wording: “‘झूला’ (1962) का गीत ‘एक समय पर दो बरसातें’ (मन्ना डे, सुर मल्हार+मेघ+मियाँ की मल्हार) के शास्त्रीय रंगों के साथ स्वरों का उतार-चढ़ाव भी बहुत ही प्रभावी असर पैदा करता है।” · Applies to: mixed

Need the attribution logic? Read how film-song raags are identified.